![]() |
barnesandnoble.com |
War is…by Marc Aronson
Module 5 History, Biography and Nonfiction
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Aronson, Marc, and Patricia J. Campbell. War is--: soldiers, survivors, and storytellers talk about war. Cambridge, Mass.: Candlewick Press, 2008. ISBN 9780763636258
CRITICAL ANALYSIS
Editors Marc Aronson and Patty Campbell do not pretend to have unbiased feelings toward America’s participation in wars. This compilation of interviews, plays, poetry and memoirs provides a varied look at the horrors of war. It does not however, offer an impartial debate with various perspectives represented. This book’s sole intent is to expose readers a specific component of military service-war.
Readers will hear firsthand from soldiers, civilians and parents of military members how savage war is. Accounts of what life is like after a war has been waged are also included and are even more difficult to contemplate.
This resource presents authentic and accurate narrative opinions from the distinct perspective of service men and women who signed up for military service with no intention of fighting in battles. However, it may prove to be more effective in its intended purpose-to persuade readers not to support war- if it included accounts from military personnel and their families who felt compelled and honored to serve their country at times of war. I feel the stories of their sacrifice alongside the stories of those who served only because they had no other choice, would lend more credibility to the editors’ argument that war is horrid. When readers learn of the tragedies the military face on and off the battle field they may begin to feel gratitude for the ransoms paid for their freedom. Perhaps they would then be more apt to support the men and women who gave of themselves and look for ways to avoid war in the future.
BOOK HOOK/EXPLEMPLARY OR FAVORITE LINES/STUDENT REVIEWS
“WAR IS…
Crazy, History, Deception, Unbearable, Delusion, Male, Linked with religion, Worse for Civilians, Impossible to Win, Inevitable?” (Aronson 3-6)
STUDENT REVIEWAllison's review
Jul 09, 11
bookshelves: ya-lit
Read in July, 2011
This book was interesting. I like the different perspectives they gave from different wars, but it still felt kind of biased. I thought that this book was more about showing both sides of the war debate, and less about discouraging future generations from making was in the first place. I agree that war is a terrible thing, but I also think it's currently a necessary thing. It seemed like the book was kind of pacifist. It was not what I expected, and a little disappointing, but not bad overall.
Warnings: There's some cursing (up to the f-bomb), some yucky descriptions of dead people, and mentions of sexual harassment, but this is about soldiers and war, so it shouldn't be too unexpected.
EXTERNAL ASSESSMENTS
School Library Journal
Aronson and Campbell have collected an outstanding array of essays, interviews, blog posts, articles, song lyrics, short stories, and letters from people directly involved in war. The book is broken into sections called "Deciding About War," "Experiencing War," and "The Aftermath of War." A former soldier writes an open letter to young enlistees, hoping they will scrutinize their reasons for joining up. The U.S. military recruitment contract is minutely examined by a high school social studies teacher. World War II reporter Ernie Pyle's articles on D-Day are reprinted. An essay about women soldiers who served in Iraq is excerpted from Helen Benedict's forthcoming book, The Lonely Soldier. And a memoir by poet Fumiko Miura, survivor of the atomic bomb at Nagasaki, is included. The volume closes with a short play and a short story about the aftereffects of war. The editors make it plain that they are antiwar, but they have made an effort to convey a variety of experiences. Overall, however, war is shown to be brutal, life-changing (not for the better), and ongoing. Aronson notes that humans have gone to war for all of recorded history and show no signs of stopping now. Many books about war for young people make it seem glamorous, exciting, and noble. This powerful collection shows its inglorious, perhaps more realistic side.
Booklist
In his provocatively titled introduction, “People Like War,” Aronson writes: “If we ask people to fight for us—as we always have and always will—we owe them the respect of listening to them.” Though differing (passionately) about war’s inevitability, his coeditor, Campbell, feels likewise, and joins him in presenting a gathering of reminiscences, interviews, letters, published articles, and literary works that brilliantly convey war’s terrible appeal as well as its realities and lasting effects on those whose lives are personally touched by armed conflict. Contributions include Ernie Pyle’s eloquent account of wreckage on a D-Day beach, a Vietnam vet’s nightmarish memories of combat, jokey letters home by Campbell’s naive doughboy father, scathing accounts of sexual harassment in Iraq and elsewhere from several female ex-GIs, and a disturbing indictment of recruiting practices in today’s high schools. Anyone considering enlistment will find these pieces (not to mention the many titles provided in the ample but not indigestible lists of war fiction and nonfiction at the end) to be mesmerizing reading. With this collection, Aronson and Campbell have provided an uncommonly valuable source of hard information and perceptive insight.